(Part 2) What I've Learned From Interviewing Nearly 50 of America's Top Agents
Different markets. Different personalities. Different business models. The same lessons kept showing up anyway.
In Part 1, I wrote about three themes that kept showing up in my conversations with some of the top agents in America. Relationships mattered more than transactions. Boring beats exciting more often than we’d like to admit. And the people who seemed to win the biggest often played a much longer game than everyone around them.
What surprised me even more was what happened when the conversations drifted away from real estate.
Because eventually they always did.
We’d start by talking about listings, lead generation, marketing, recruiting, growth, or production. Then, somewhere along the way, the conversation would shift. We’d start talking about leadership, decision making, team building, communication, accountability, and trust. The longer I hosted the podcast, the less it felt like I was interviewing real estate agents and the more it felt like I was interviewing business owners, coaches, and leaders who happened to sell houses.
In fact, after nearly fifty interviews, I started noticing something that felt almost backwards. The most successful people in the business seemed to spend the least amount of time talking about houses.
Aaron Kirman operates at a level most agents will never experience firsthand. Tracy Tutor has built one of the most recognizable brands in luxury real estate. Tom Toole has built a high-performing team while coaching and mentoring agents across the country. Yet none of them spent much time talking about countertops, square footage, or listing presentations. They talked about systems. They talked about people. They talked about creating businesses that could continue operating at a high level even when they weren’t personally touching every transaction.
That was my first clue.
Freedom Doesn’t Come From Fewer Systems
Most agents get into the business chasing freedom. Freedom from a boss. Freedom from a schedule. Freedom from somebody telling them where they need to be at nine o’clock on a Monday morning. It’s one of the reasons real estate attracts entrepreneurial personalities in the first place.
What’s interesting is that many of the most successful people I interviewed eventually discovered something that sounds completely contradictory. Freedom doesn’t come from having fewer systems. It comes from having better systems.
The agents with the most freedom often seemed to have the most structure. They talked about processes, expectations, standards, calendars, and accountability. They built operating systems around their businesses the same way a pilot builds a checklist before taking off. Nobody wants a pilot to wing it. Nobody wants a surgeon to improvise. Yet for some reason, many agents spend years believing success comes from flexibility rather than structure.
The people I interviewed seemed to understand the opposite. Structure created freedom because structure removed decisions. Every process eliminated friction. Every system reduced chaos. Every standard made it easier to deliver a consistent experience.
I’ve written before that environment shapes behavior more than effort. Systems are really just environments you’ve intentionally built. They help you do the right things when motivation disappears, and motivation always disappears eventually. The agents who seemed to have the most control over their businesses weren’t relying on discipline every day. They weren’t waking up each morning hoping they felt productive. They were operating inside systems that made success more likely and mistakes less costly.
The result wasn’t less freedom. It was more.
At Some Point, Everything Becomes Leadership
The second thing that kept showing up was leadership.
Not leadership in the conference-speaker sense. Not leadership in the LinkedIn-post sense. Real leadership. The messy kind. The kind that involves difficult conversations, managing expectations, solving problems, and helping other people become successful.
Almost every conversation started in one place and ended somewhere else.
We’d begin by discussing sales and production. Then somehow we’d find ourselves talking about recruiting, culture, communication, coaching, and trust. Leigh Brown was a great example. Leigh has built an extraordinary career and one of the strongest personal brands in the industry, but what stood out in our conversation wasn’t production. It was people.
The same thing happened with brokerage owners, team leaders, and operators throughout the series. The larger their businesses became, the less they talked about themselves, and the more they talked about everyone around them.
At some point, the scoreboard changes.
Early in your career, success is measured by what you can personally accomplish. Listings taken. Buyers served. Transactions closed. Then something shifts. The question becomes less about your own performance and more about the performance of the people around you. How do you help someone else improve? How do you create culture? How do you communicate expectations? How do you build trust? How do you help someone avoid mistakes you spent years making yourself?
The more successful the guest, the more likely the conversation eventually landed there.
And that’s when the biggest realization hit me.
The Best Agents Aren’t Really In The Real Estate Business
I know that sounds ridiculous. Stay with me.
When I started the podcast, I assumed the most successful agents would know more about houses than everyone else. And they do. They understand contracts, pricing strategies, negotiations, financing, and marketing at an incredibly high level.
But that’s not what separated them.
What separated them was how well they understood people.
Think about Amy Stockberger’s philosophy around transformation and lifetime value. Think about Ricky Carruth’s emphasis on relationships and community. Think about Charlie Wills building depth of relationship rather than dependency on purchased leads. Think about Leigh Brown’s focus on connection and leadership.
Different businesses. Different personalities. Same pattern.
The best agents seemed far more interested in understanding trust, communication, reputation, relationships, influence, and human behavior than they were in understanding houses.
The more I thought about it, the more it made sense.
A house doesn’t decide whether to refer you.
A house doesn’t decide whether to trust you.
A house doesn’t remember how you handled a difficult transaction.
A house doesn’t tell its friends about you.
People do.
That’s why communication matters. That’s why reputation matters. That’s why leadership matters. That’s why relationships matter. Those things aren’t soft skills sitting off to the side of the business. They are the business. The house is simply the setting where the business happens.
What Nearly Fifty Conversations Taught Me
Looking back across nearly fifty conversations, I expected to find a collection of tactics. Instead, I found a collection of principles.
Part 1 was largely about what these agents do. Relationships. Consistency. Patience.
This article is really about who they become.
Builders. Leaders. Connectors. People who understand that success eventually becomes less about managing transactions and more about creating environments where trust can grow.
The funny thing is that if you asked most of them to describe themselves, they probably wouldn’t use any of those words. They’d likely tell you they’re just doing their job.
Maybe that’s part of the lesson, too.
The people who spend the least amount of time talking about success often seem to spend the most amount of time building it.
If you’ve enjoyed these conversations, I’d encourage you to check out Real Estate Insiders Unfiltered on YouTube, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen. Every guest has a different story, but what surprised me most is how often those stories arrived at the same destination.
-k
If you enjoyed this article, consider subscribing.
Most weeks I write about real estate, business, leadership, decision making, and the lessons that seem to surface after conversations with some of the smartest people I’ve met. Sometimes the topic is real estate. Sometimes it isn’t. Either way, the goal is the same: to share ideas that might help you think a little differently about your business, your career, and the people around you.
If that sounds like something you’d enjoy, I’d love to have you join us.